A paperfolding paradise
The website of writer and paperfolding designer David Mitchell
|Charles Dodgson (aka Lewis Carroll) / John Tenniel|
page attempts to record what is known about paperfolding
in the works of Charles Dodgson (aka Lewis Carrol) and
John Tenniel.Please contact me if you know any of this
information is incorrect or if you have any other
information that should be added. Thank you.
This 1872 illustration by John Tenniel, now held in the Victoria and Albert Museum, for the Lewis Carroll poem 'The Walrus and the Carpenter' shows the carpenter wearing a paper hat, as do several other illustrations by Tenniel for the same poem.
Another John Tenniel illustration, this time for Lewis Carroll's 'Through the Looking-Glass, and What Alice Found There', first published in 1871, shows Alice in a railway carriage sitting opposite a man wearing a white paper suit and a Newspaper Hat. According to Martin Gardner (in 'The Annotated Alice, 1998, p.218) the fact that the man is dressed in white paper is a political joke. He believes that Tenniels illustration shows a cartoon of Benjamin Disraeli and that Tenniel may have had in mind the white papers (official documents) with which such statesmen are surrounded. Before he illustrated the Alice books, Tenniel had once portrayed Disraeli in a Government White Paper suit. However, Michael Hancher, writing in 'The Tenniel Illustrations to the Alice Books, 1985' disputes this identification as the man in white paper does not have the obvious chin or goatee, which are normally present in Tenniels caricatures of Disraeli. Source: http://www.alice-in-wonderland.net/resources/analysis/picture-origins/
In 1972 the British Origami Society issued Pamphlet No 1 'Some Notes on the History of Origami' which was written by John Smith. In August 1973 a revised version was issued which included some additional notes on Lewis Carroll's paper folding.
In this revised booklet John Smith gave 7 excerpts from Lewis Carroll's diaries which mention paper folding. These can also be found on his website at http://www.britishorigami.info/academic/johnsmith/history_notes.php which also gives sources and page numbers for them (which I have not checked). In date order these are:
June 7th 1889 - 'With ... Princess Alice and her brother, Duke of Albany ... and folded a fishing boat for them.'
October 2nd 1890 - 'Called on Mrs Fox with whose children I began an acquaintance at the concert the other night: Annie (aged 8) and Stanley. Today I borrowed the children for an hour qand took them to my lodgings and folded fishing boats for them, etc.'
October 8th 1890 - '... and the little boy Francis Epipharius (Piffy), a very bright little creature, who taught me how to fold paper pistols ...'
October 1891 - 'Princess Alice and the little Duke of Albany, however, paid him a visit and were initiated in the art of making paper pistols.'
November 16th 1891 - 'The Duchess of Albany is at the Deanery with her children and sent the children to my rooms soon after 10 ... and I taught them to fold paper pistols ...'
January 26th 1897 - 'In the afternoon I went to Godalming and had tea with the vicar, and folded a fishing boat and paper pistol for his little Mary.'
August 28th 1897 - 'Fetched Edith Wardell to tea, and little Nora Charrington, aged 7, for whom I folded a fishing boat etc.'
There is also a passage in the Easy Read Comfort Edition of 'The Life and Letters of Lewis Carroll' published by ReadHowYouWant in 2008 and dated to June 1889 which reads: 'Once at luncheon I had the Duchess (of Albany) as neighbour and once at breakfast, and had several other chats with her, and found her very pleasant indeed. Princess Alice is a sweet little girl. Her little brother (the Duke of Albany) was entirely fascinating, a perfect little prince, and the picture of good-humour. On Sunday afternoon I had a pleasant half-hour with the children, telling them "Bruno's Picnic" and folding a fishing-boat for them.'
On his website 'Bits of Smith', John Smith also gives another reference from 'The Magic of Lewis Carroll', edited by John Fisher, Nelson, 1973, in which he quotes a further passage from Lewis Carroll's diaries which reads. "We were playing on the fort at Margate, and a gentleman on a seat near asked us if we could make a paper boat, with a seat at each end and a basket in the middle for fish." This sounds like a description of the Chinese Junk. No date for this incident is given, however, this description suggests that the folded paper fishing boats referred to on several other occasions in Lewis Carroll's diaries may be Chinese Junks rather than, as I had always previously assumed, the much simpler paper boat design made from the newspaper hat.
The other design mentioned in these excerpts, the paper pistol, is harder to identify. It may be what we now call the traditional banger, or it may be the two-piece pistol made from rolled sheets of paper, or something else entirely. There is simply no evidence to tell us.
Finally it is worth noting that while Lewis Carroll may have valued paper folding as a way of entertaining children he was not a fan of paperfolding as a way of teaching mathematics. On page 11 of his book 'A History of Folding in Mathematics', Birkhauser, 2018, Michael Friedmann refers to Charles Dodgson's book 'Euclid and his Modern Rivals', published in 1885, in which, inter alia, he compares Euclidean proofs with proofs based on paperfolding and remarks ' ... (a)ll that about folding and re-folding the paper is more like a child's book of puzzles than a scientific treatise. I should be very sorry to be the school-boy who is expected to learn this precious demonstration!'